The Dirty Details of Poaching and Stealing Another Agent’s Business

It is EVER okay to dabble in this to get yourself further ahead?

Property management is a very important part of any real estate business – providing financial strength and stability.

However, there is a darker side with respect to the actions of a few that can cause considerable damage to the business of others, as well as to their own professional reputation and good standing.

Poaching and stealing someone else’s management and business is something that should not be taken lightly. There is a fair play way of getting business from a competitor, and there is a dirty way that we should never accept as professionals.

Poaching Business

I categorise this as the direct and deliberate taking of another agent’s business. That may involve directly and knowingly approaching someone else’s clients, persuading them to cancel their current agency agreement, and transferring the business over to them. Property Managers may send direct letters to the client (without disclaimers) to persuade them to sign over to their agency. They may call the client after seeing their property advertised with another agent. They may find out where the client lives and approach them directly.

I remember attending a national property managers conference in 2004 and during the evening cocktail party a property manager proudly boasted to me that one of her ‘rent roll growth strategies’ was to call another agent’s landlords should their rental property be in the newspaper classifieds ‘to let’ section for more than one week. I clearly shared with her my opinion on this and stated that if she was my competition and she did that to me, I would not deal with her on any level with future communication and general dealings!

There is a right way when it comes to getting new business. If you are approached first by the client and they wish to transfer over their business to you, then this action is quite fair and justified! They need to ensure that their management agreement with the other agent is cancelled (in writing) first before you have the legal right to manage their property.

Sometimes we may conduct a direct mailing to landlords. You must ensure that you have a disclaimer on the bottom of your letter/material such as: ‘Please disregard this letter/material should you be in a contractual agreement with another agent.’ If you find out they are with another agent and were not aware originally, do not persist in getting their business! Invite them to call you should they ever be considering using another service but leave it at that!

Stealing Business

This is where a property manager leaves a company and then directly contacts their former clients to bring their business over to the new company where they are now employed. They are cashing in on the goodwill and relationship that they first established with the client at their former employment. I have even heard of property managers contacting the clients just before they have finalised their employment!

Without discussing the possibility for litigation against that property manager by their former employer, let’s take a good look at this! The business belongs to that former principal! They acted in good faith and employed and paid the property manager to manage that business! It does not belong to that property manager despite the relationship and goodwill they have created!

The property manager has no right whatsoever to contact those clients. He/she has taken advantage of the previous relationship they had with the client to transfer their business over.

My only advice to any property manager leaving their position and taking their employer’s business with them is simply DON’T! Just walk away, do not take any computer print off landlord name/address lists with you, and do not contact any clients!

It all really comes down to the fact that if we are to take business away from another agent, the first approach must be made by the client. We do not actively pursue this business by directly contacting them!

The property manager who is poaching or stealing this business may have a short-term gain but it is not worth the bad reputation that will spread by word of mouth amongst other property managers and principals in your area.

Growing the rent roll can be done in so many ways without having to poach and steal it from someone else.

We must ensure our industry is strong and gaining new business in a professional and ethical way that benefits everyone!