Strategy #7 - Converting Private Landlords to Full Management: A Proven Strategy
(15 minutes)

Managing properties can be overwhelming, particularly for private landlords who take on the responsibility themselves.

This approach focuses on converting self-managing landlords into full property management clients, addressing their common pain points and showcasing the benefits of working with a professional property manager.

In this chapter, we’ll cover five key steps to help you effectively reach out to these landlords and demonstrate how to add value.

Step 1: Identify Privately Managed Properties

The first step to converting private landlords is knowing where to find them. Various online platforms are excellent for locating these properties that will likely be marketed directly by owners.

1. Facebook Marketplace
Start by searching for rental listings on Facebook Marketplace. Use the location radius feature to refine your search within specific areas, allowing you to focus on nearby opportunities.

You can find both whole homes and rooms for rent, which may help you identify tenants subletting – a practice that often slips under private landlords’ radars.

2. Rental Applications
Rental applications that pass through your agency could also be sources of leads. The BDM should establish direct contact with private landlords.

3. Real Estate Websites
Sites like Realestate.com.au (Australia) and Trademe.co.nz (New Zealand) often list properties managed by private owners. Additionally, a quick Google search like “Where can a private landlord advertise their property for rent?” will provide a list of local platforms, giving you more lead sources.

Tip: Use these insights to create social media posts or video content that educates landlords on self-management risks, such as a lack of thorough screening, which could allow ‘bad tenants’ to rent their property.

Furthermore, advertising themselves may attract bad tenants who refuse to deal with property managers because they know how thorough the screening process will be, and they recognise that a private landlord is an easy target.

Bonus: If you know the statistics on how many applications you process per month or week, and how many you approve in comparison as a percentage, share these statistics as proof of your expertise.

For example,

[Script] “Mr. Smith, out of 100 tenant applications we receive a month, did you know that after we have screened them thoroughly, we find that only about 40% can be approved, should we have something available to rent?”

Step 2: Reach Out to Private Landlords

Once you’ve identified potential clients, reaching out tactfully is essential.

Start with an introductory phone call that offers help rather than a hard sell.

[Script] “Hi [Landlord’s Name], my name is [Your Name] from [Your Agency]. I noticed that your property is currently listed for rent, and I wanted to see if I could assist you.

I’d be happy to share some tips with you on attracting tenants and can even send over a guide with our top ten marketing tips. Would you be open to receiving some support?”

The opening script isn’t asking them to give you the management; you are calling and offering assistance to help them.

Pain Point Awareness

Remember that many private landlords face challenges such as vacancies, tenant issues, and property upkeep.

By addressing these, you establish yourself as a knowledgeable, supportive resource they can rely on.

Step 3: Provide Valuable Resources

After connecting with a landlord, back up your offer with practical resources to help them market and manage their property better.

This approach gives private landlords a glimpse into the level of support they’d receive under professional management.

Examples of Helpful Resources to Send:

Guides: For example, ‘TEN Ways to Market Your Property’ or ‘How to Reduce the Stress of Self-Managing a Property.’

• Videos and Articles: Share links to educational videos or articles on topics like effective tenant screening or compliance with property regulations.

• Templates and Checklists: Providing checklists for inspections or move-ins gives landlords an insight into the detail-oriented nature of professional management.

• Legislation Changes and Fines: Any updated legislation change that can enforce a fine or even a change to insurance if the said property isn’t compliant.

This value-packed follow-up establishes credibility and showcases your agency’s capabilities without overwhelming them.

Step 4: Offer a ‘Lease-Only’ Service Option

Not all landlords will immediately jump to full property management, but a ‘lease-only’ service provides a middle ground. Here’s how to approach it:

If interested, offer a lease-only service for a higher-than-standard let fee.

For example, consider charging double for a lease-only service. This service can include:

• Tenant Screening and Lease Signing
• Ingoing Condition Reports
• Insurance and Compliance Checks (e.g., smoke alarms)

If they have agreed to the lease only option, and you are charging an extra fee for this (standard let fee might be 1 week’s rent, lease only could be 2 weeks' rent).

So the extra weeks' rent you have charged for the lease only could be equal to, say 10 weeks of a rental management fee (depending on the rental amount and your fees).

If this is the case, you have made the money for the equal amount of managing the property for a period of time, so offer to manage the property for that said time, complimentary.

This ‘lease-only’ arrangement introduces landlords to professional property management while allowing them to maintain some involvement.

Step 5: Follow-Up Consistently

The follow-up phase is crucial in converting landlords.
If they initially seem uninterested or stop responding, remain persistent. Send a friendly video message or email sharing additional tips. For example:

[Script] “Hi [Landlord’s Name], I noticed your property is still on the market. Don’t forget the essentials, such as smoke alarm checks and securing the property. Let me know if there’s anything I can do to help.”

Highlight Consequences of Non-Compliance

At this stage, you may also want to share a list of potential penalties for non-compliance with legislation, especially as property laws grow stricter in markets like Australia and New Zealand.

Many landlords don’t fully realise the complexity of legal requirements, and this can prompt them to consider hiring a professional manager.

Converting private landlords into full property management clients can be challenging, but by following these steps, property managers can position themselves as trusted experts.

By educating landlords on the benefits and removing the obstacles they face in self-management, you build a strong case for your services.

Would you like to add coaching and accountability to get better results?

If you’d like more hands-on support with this strategy, consider exploring resources like LeadMachineSystem.com or booking a session with Deniz Yusuf at LeadMachineChat.com.

The more you put into place, the better results you’ll see in winning over private landlords.

LEAD MACHINE SECRETS

Grow your Rent Roll- 28 Ways!

​​​Revealed...secrets to 28 effective ways to attract warm leads to grow your rent roll without relying on salespeople.

PM FEE SCRIPTS SECRETS

Access 50 (plus) fee objection responses.

[UNLOCKED] How to WIN the deal and your FULL FEES with CONFIDENCE...no matter how low your rivals discount or reduce their fees.

​​​Every PM fee objection you'll ever face has an effective response! ​You'll find it...in this book!

MASTER YOUR
​TIME SECRETS

The kick-butt time management handbook for crazy busy property managers who want to beat burn-out, reduce stress, take control and get their life back!

WIN YOUR WORTH SECRETS

The complete PM HANDBOOK on how to WIN THE BEST FEES with new clients and INCREASE YOUR FEES with your current clients without losing them to cheaper agents

BDM Coach Podcast Show

BDM skills and techniques that will take you to 20-30 properties a month.

Top Growth Podcast Show

Rent Roll Growth Strategies...ready to go!

Win Your Worth Podcast Show

How to win the best property management fees in the marketing with confidence, no matter how cheap your rivals discount or reduce their fees.

IGT Logo png

All Rights Reserved 2025. inspiredgrowthtraining.com